Product Critic

Owner → Hermes → Specialist Agents
DCP READ-ONLY: CONNECTED DEVELOPMENT / UI PREVIEW DCP BATCH 5/6 SOAK IN PROGRESS TELEMETRY: UNKNOWN COMMAND EXECUTION LOCKED

Product Critic — detail

Profile

UNKNOWNPRODUCT PLANNINGR1
Agent ID
product-critic
Title
Product Critic
Role
Product Critic
Focus
Challenge · Review · Scope · Risk
Team
PRODUCT PLANNING
Status
UNKNOWN
Memory scope
project
Registry state
UNKNOWN

Capabilities

prd.review scope.audit risk.identify assumption.challenge reuse.recommend

Responsibilities

  • challenges assumptions in ideas and PRDs
  • detects scope creep and overengineering
  • finds hidden dependencies
  • identifies untestable acceptance criteria
  • recommends reuse and smaller MVPs
  • identifies kill criteria before build

Product Critic — review scope

Capabilities

Challenge assumptions Detect scope creep Detect overengineering Find hidden dependencies Identify untestable acceptance criteria Recommend reuse Recommend smaller MVP Identify kill criteria

Responsibility

Reviews proposals and PRDs before build: challenges assumptions, detects scope creep and overengineering, finds hidden dependencies, flags untestable acceptance criteria, recommends reuse and smaller MVPs, and identifies kill criteria.

Authority (STATIC CONFIG)

  • review / proposal only
  • no approval authority
  • no execution path

Role shown from STATIC CONFIG / MOCK — review/proposal only. No approval or execution path.

Risk policy

LevelDecisionMeaning
R0ALLOWEDread-only / information
R1ALLOWEDlow-risk action + audit
R2POLICY CONTROLLEDbounded autonomous action after checks
R3APPROVAL REQUIREDowner approval required
R4MANUAL ONLYautonomous execution prohibited

Policy defaults (STATIC CONFIG). This agent's registry risk ceiling is R1 (STATIC CONFIG). Agent-specific grants are not claimed unless supported.

Model assignment

Current model
CONFIGURED LATER
Preferred model
CONFIGURED LATER
Fallback model
CONFIGURED LATER
Provider
UNKNOWN
Routing policy
UNKNOWN

Why this model?

CONFIGURED LATER

Agent identity is NOT bound to one permanent model. Selection is expected to become dynamic routing.

Model assignment source: MOCK — runtime model telemetry API not available yet.

Current work

No current task.

Task history / metrics

Runs (window)
N/A
Success rate
N/A
Last latency
N/A
Token use
N/A
Estimated cost
N/A

Source: REAL no AI Ops runs recorded for this agent in the read window

Recent activity

No recent activity readable for this agent.

← Back to directory